How long can an adult survive on pure carbs?
In reference to the classic Indestructible Edible Trope, how long can an adult subsist on largely junk food? I realize that "largely" is vague, so feel free to clarify as desired to give a helpful answer (one way or the other). To motivate things:
Imagine a world shortly after the apocalypse. Something very quickly resulted in the "depopulation" of most of the USA (or similar country). Best bet is a virulent plague with a 95% mortality rate. Because of how quickly it spread and killed people, those who survived the plague have basically found themselves in a "fairly" undisturbed world. For the purposes of this question that mainly means that grocery stores, gas stations, etc, are mostly still stocked with goods.
Of course power goes out quickly, so anything that needs to be refrigerated goes bad very soon. This leaves hardier staples, but from what I can tell the longest lasting foods are largely pure carbs with very little nutrition other than calories. Some examples:
- Dry pasta (1-2 years)
- White rice (4-5 years, but only 6-8 months for brown rice)
- Unpopped popcorn (indefinitely)
- Cereal (6-8 months)
My own impressions lead me to believe that these are also some of the more common items in a grocery store, and so they would be the easiest to find in large quantities for a post-apocalyptic scavenger. However, these foods (especially white rice and white pasta) have very little nutritional value other than calories and some minerals. Certainly very little protein, and no fat - fat especially would make them go bad faster, I suspect, so high-fat foods are most likely out after a few months (although I think canned nuts might last 6 months or a bit more).
Still, our survivors need to figure out how to become independent and produce their own food without the help of modern infrastructure. For the purposes of this question our survivors apparently have access to sufficient quantities of clean water as well as shelter. We're ignoring the risk posed by large quantities of dead bodies rotting everywhere. The survivor(s) are small in numbers and we'll presume there is enough food left in stores: the only thing that will hamper their long-term scavenging is the expiration date of the food (the actual one, not the one printed on the back).
How long do our survivors have to figure out how to become self-sufficient with food sources before malnutrition becomes a serious problem? Or can they survive more or less indefinitely off of such low-quality food? I'm also open to frame challenges, aka let me know if there are actually more than enough nutritious and long-lasting food sources around and there is nothing to worry about.
post-apocalypse food
add a comment |
In reference to the classic Indestructible Edible Trope, how long can an adult subsist on largely junk food? I realize that "largely" is vague, so feel free to clarify as desired to give a helpful answer (one way or the other). To motivate things:
Imagine a world shortly after the apocalypse. Something very quickly resulted in the "depopulation" of most of the USA (or similar country). Best bet is a virulent plague with a 95% mortality rate. Because of how quickly it spread and killed people, those who survived the plague have basically found themselves in a "fairly" undisturbed world. For the purposes of this question that mainly means that grocery stores, gas stations, etc, are mostly still stocked with goods.
Of course power goes out quickly, so anything that needs to be refrigerated goes bad very soon. This leaves hardier staples, but from what I can tell the longest lasting foods are largely pure carbs with very little nutrition other than calories. Some examples:
- Dry pasta (1-2 years)
- White rice (4-5 years, but only 6-8 months for brown rice)
- Unpopped popcorn (indefinitely)
- Cereal (6-8 months)
My own impressions lead me to believe that these are also some of the more common items in a grocery store, and so they would be the easiest to find in large quantities for a post-apocalyptic scavenger. However, these foods (especially white rice and white pasta) have very little nutritional value other than calories and some minerals. Certainly very little protein, and no fat - fat especially would make them go bad faster, I suspect, so high-fat foods are most likely out after a few months (although I think canned nuts might last 6 months or a bit more).
Still, our survivors need to figure out how to become independent and produce their own food without the help of modern infrastructure. For the purposes of this question our survivors apparently have access to sufficient quantities of clean water as well as shelter. We're ignoring the risk posed by large quantities of dead bodies rotting everywhere. The survivor(s) are small in numbers and we'll presume there is enough food left in stores: the only thing that will hamper their long-term scavenging is the expiration date of the food (the actual one, not the one printed on the back).
How long do our survivors have to figure out how to become self-sufficient with food sources before malnutrition becomes a serious problem? Or can they survive more or less indefinitely off of such low-quality food? I'm also open to frame challenges, aka let me know if there are actually more than enough nutritious and long-lasting food sources around and there is nothing to worry about.
post-apocalypse food
Dry pasta is roughly 10% protein (albeit not a complete protein.) Kept dry, it can last a long time. This is higher than white or even brown rice. On the other hand, unpopped popcorn could be used as planting seed, as could most dry beans.
– Catalyst
2 hours ago
Please clarify: Is the question how long one can survive on a fairly-pure carb diet (e.g. just white rice?) OR, is the question what are the most valuable additions to that diet, to make it viable in the long term? Or something else entirely??
– Catalyst
1 hour ago
2
Dry beans also keep a long time and are a complete protein, with pretty good vitamin content. Not sure how long you'd stay sane living on beans and nothing else, but you could live a long time...
– Zeiss Ikon
1 hour ago
@Catalyst the former: how long can one survive on a fairly pure-carb diet? Your other question is basically "what can a post-apocalyptic scavenger do to improve nutrition?" which is related and of interest to me, but I think it would be too broad to throw that in as well. However, I think it would be fair to tell me if my main assumption (i.e. pure carbs are the primary food source) is wrong.
– conman
49 mins ago
add a comment |
In reference to the classic Indestructible Edible Trope, how long can an adult subsist on largely junk food? I realize that "largely" is vague, so feel free to clarify as desired to give a helpful answer (one way or the other). To motivate things:
Imagine a world shortly after the apocalypse. Something very quickly resulted in the "depopulation" of most of the USA (or similar country). Best bet is a virulent plague with a 95% mortality rate. Because of how quickly it spread and killed people, those who survived the plague have basically found themselves in a "fairly" undisturbed world. For the purposes of this question that mainly means that grocery stores, gas stations, etc, are mostly still stocked with goods.
Of course power goes out quickly, so anything that needs to be refrigerated goes bad very soon. This leaves hardier staples, but from what I can tell the longest lasting foods are largely pure carbs with very little nutrition other than calories. Some examples:
- Dry pasta (1-2 years)
- White rice (4-5 years, but only 6-8 months for brown rice)
- Unpopped popcorn (indefinitely)
- Cereal (6-8 months)
My own impressions lead me to believe that these are also some of the more common items in a grocery store, and so they would be the easiest to find in large quantities for a post-apocalyptic scavenger. However, these foods (especially white rice and white pasta) have very little nutritional value other than calories and some minerals. Certainly very little protein, and no fat - fat especially would make them go bad faster, I suspect, so high-fat foods are most likely out after a few months (although I think canned nuts might last 6 months or a bit more).
Still, our survivors need to figure out how to become independent and produce their own food without the help of modern infrastructure. For the purposes of this question our survivors apparently have access to sufficient quantities of clean water as well as shelter. We're ignoring the risk posed by large quantities of dead bodies rotting everywhere. The survivor(s) are small in numbers and we'll presume there is enough food left in stores: the only thing that will hamper their long-term scavenging is the expiration date of the food (the actual one, not the one printed on the back).
How long do our survivors have to figure out how to become self-sufficient with food sources before malnutrition becomes a serious problem? Or can they survive more or less indefinitely off of such low-quality food? I'm also open to frame challenges, aka let me know if there are actually more than enough nutritious and long-lasting food sources around and there is nothing to worry about.
post-apocalypse food
In reference to the classic Indestructible Edible Trope, how long can an adult subsist on largely junk food? I realize that "largely" is vague, so feel free to clarify as desired to give a helpful answer (one way or the other). To motivate things:
Imagine a world shortly after the apocalypse. Something very quickly resulted in the "depopulation" of most of the USA (or similar country). Best bet is a virulent plague with a 95% mortality rate. Because of how quickly it spread and killed people, those who survived the plague have basically found themselves in a "fairly" undisturbed world. For the purposes of this question that mainly means that grocery stores, gas stations, etc, are mostly still stocked with goods.
Of course power goes out quickly, so anything that needs to be refrigerated goes bad very soon. This leaves hardier staples, but from what I can tell the longest lasting foods are largely pure carbs with very little nutrition other than calories. Some examples:
- Dry pasta (1-2 years)
- White rice (4-5 years, but only 6-8 months for brown rice)
- Unpopped popcorn (indefinitely)
- Cereal (6-8 months)
My own impressions lead me to believe that these are also some of the more common items in a grocery store, and so they would be the easiest to find in large quantities for a post-apocalyptic scavenger. However, these foods (especially white rice and white pasta) have very little nutritional value other than calories and some minerals. Certainly very little protein, and no fat - fat especially would make them go bad faster, I suspect, so high-fat foods are most likely out after a few months (although I think canned nuts might last 6 months or a bit more).
Still, our survivors need to figure out how to become independent and produce their own food without the help of modern infrastructure. For the purposes of this question our survivors apparently have access to sufficient quantities of clean water as well as shelter. We're ignoring the risk posed by large quantities of dead bodies rotting everywhere. The survivor(s) are small in numbers and we'll presume there is enough food left in stores: the only thing that will hamper their long-term scavenging is the expiration date of the food (the actual one, not the one printed on the back).
How long do our survivors have to figure out how to become self-sufficient with food sources before malnutrition becomes a serious problem? Or can they survive more or less indefinitely off of such low-quality food? I'm also open to frame challenges, aka let me know if there are actually more than enough nutritious and long-lasting food sources around and there is nothing to worry about.
post-apocalypse food
post-apocalypse food
edited 16 mins ago
asked 2 hours ago
conman
4008
4008
Dry pasta is roughly 10% protein (albeit not a complete protein.) Kept dry, it can last a long time. This is higher than white or even brown rice. On the other hand, unpopped popcorn could be used as planting seed, as could most dry beans.
– Catalyst
2 hours ago
Please clarify: Is the question how long one can survive on a fairly-pure carb diet (e.g. just white rice?) OR, is the question what are the most valuable additions to that diet, to make it viable in the long term? Or something else entirely??
– Catalyst
1 hour ago
2
Dry beans also keep a long time and are a complete protein, with pretty good vitamin content. Not sure how long you'd stay sane living on beans and nothing else, but you could live a long time...
– Zeiss Ikon
1 hour ago
@Catalyst the former: how long can one survive on a fairly pure-carb diet? Your other question is basically "what can a post-apocalyptic scavenger do to improve nutrition?" which is related and of interest to me, but I think it would be too broad to throw that in as well. However, I think it would be fair to tell me if my main assumption (i.e. pure carbs are the primary food source) is wrong.
– conman
49 mins ago
add a comment |
Dry pasta is roughly 10% protein (albeit not a complete protein.) Kept dry, it can last a long time. This is higher than white or even brown rice. On the other hand, unpopped popcorn could be used as planting seed, as could most dry beans.
– Catalyst
2 hours ago
Please clarify: Is the question how long one can survive on a fairly-pure carb diet (e.g. just white rice?) OR, is the question what are the most valuable additions to that diet, to make it viable in the long term? Or something else entirely??
– Catalyst
1 hour ago
2
Dry beans also keep a long time and are a complete protein, with pretty good vitamin content. Not sure how long you'd stay sane living on beans and nothing else, but you could live a long time...
– Zeiss Ikon
1 hour ago
@Catalyst the former: how long can one survive on a fairly pure-carb diet? Your other question is basically "what can a post-apocalyptic scavenger do to improve nutrition?" which is related and of interest to me, but I think it would be too broad to throw that in as well. However, I think it would be fair to tell me if my main assumption (i.e. pure carbs are the primary food source) is wrong.
– conman
49 mins ago
Dry pasta is roughly 10% protein (albeit not a complete protein.) Kept dry, it can last a long time. This is higher than white or even brown rice. On the other hand, unpopped popcorn could be used as planting seed, as could most dry beans.
– Catalyst
2 hours ago
Dry pasta is roughly 10% protein (albeit not a complete protein.) Kept dry, it can last a long time. This is higher than white or even brown rice. On the other hand, unpopped popcorn could be used as planting seed, as could most dry beans.
– Catalyst
2 hours ago
Please clarify: Is the question how long one can survive on a fairly-pure carb diet (e.g. just white rice?) OR, is the question what are the most valuable additions to that diet, to make it viable in the long term? Or something else entirely??
– Catalyst
1 hour ago
Please clarify: Is the question how long one can survive on a fairly-pure carb diet (e.g. just white rice?) OR, is the question what are the most valuable additions to that diet, to make it viable in the long term? Or something else entirely??
– Catalyst
1 hour ago
2
2
Dry beans also keep a long time and are a complete protein, with pretty good vitamin content. Not sure how long you'd stay sane living on beans and nothing else, but you could live a long time...
– Zeiss Ikon
1 hour ago
Dry beans also keep a long time and are a complete protein, with pretty good vitamin content. Not sure how long you'd stay sane living on beans and nothing else, but you could live a long time...
– Zeiss Ikon
1 hour ago
@Catalyst the former: how long can one survive on a fairly pure-carb diet? Your other question is basically "what can a post-apocalyptic scavenger do to improve nutrition?" which is related and of interest to me, but I think it would be too broad to throw that in as well. However, I think it would be fair to tell me if my main assumption (i.e. pure carbs are the primary food source) is wrong.
– conman
49 mins ago
@Catalyst the former: how long can one survive on a fairly pure-carb diet? Your other question is basically "what can a post-apocalyptic scavenger do to improve nutrition?" which is related and of interest to me, but I think it would be too broad to throw that in as well. However, I think it would be fair to tell me if my main assumption (i.e. pure carbs are the primary food source) is wrong.
– conman
49 mins ago
add a comment |
3 Answers
3
active
oldest
votes
A few months at best
It's the lack of vitamins that gets you.
Vitamin C deficiency is known colloquially as scurvy and was one of the biggest killers of sailors in the age of exploration.
Simply, you need your fruit and veg or you're going to die.
You can get around this if you have supplies of concentrated fruit juice or vitamin supplement pills, but you've got to have those vitamins.
2
Yep, scurvy was my first thought too.
– Tim B♦
1 hour ago
scurvy can be cured by extracting vitamin C from some evergreen trees, which are supposedly still healthy, by boiling the bark source. It's an old trick that european explorers learned from native american tribes when they first got there. Fruits come in season but trees always have bark, supposing our survivors know this they should be ok scurvy-wise
– Alexandre Aubrey
16 mins ago
add a comment |
Even if you have vitamin supplements stored, lack of fats will kill you before lack of protein. There's a phenomenon called "rabbit starvation" -- someone surviving in the wild whose only meat is wild rabbits will die in a few months because there isn't enough fat in the meat -- some vitamins are fat soluble and can't be absorbed, even with adequate vegetation in the diet, without enough fat intake.
Protein catabolism is a genuine issue: it's why people in WWII concentration camp photos look like living skeletons; their bodies have metabolized their own muscle to keep their brains and organs running. But if you have zero fat in a calorie-sufficient diet, you'll still waste and die even if there's enough protein to avoid digesting your own muscles.
Any idea how long that might take in an otherwise healthy (at first) adult?
– conman
1 hour ago
Given it was mentioned (by Les Stroud) as relevant to wilderness survival of someone who becomes lost in the deep woods, I'd guess the time period is two or three months -- certainly more than a week or two, likely less than half a year (anyone ought to be able to walk out in that kind of time, if they aren't injured or too weak from starvation).
– Zeiss Ikon
1 hour ago
1
Your body can make fats from carbohydrates it cant make protein from carbs. "rabbit starvation" aka protein poisoning. requires a lack of carbs as well. lack of protein may kill you first, PEM has a plethora of symptoms.
– John
23 mins ago
add a comment |
Not a problem.
There are literally food sources all around us. The only way your survivors would have to survive on "junk food" is if they were somehow trapped in an industrial city or in the middle of a desert, and even then they would learn to find alternate sources of food as part of surviving. If it's a situation where they have adequate clean water, they'll be able to find edibles.
Once they manage to get into the country, they should very quickly find other survivors who actually know how to grow food and/or have a rough understanding of which wild foods are good to eat. Heck, they'll find good food literally growing on trees or out of the ground, if they come upon an orchard or a cabbage farm.
add a comment |
Your Answer
StackExchange.ifUsing("editor", function () {
return StackExchange.using("mathjaxEditing", function () {
StackExchange.MarkdownEditor.creationCallbacks.add(function (editor, postfix) {
StackExchange.mathjaxEditing.prepareWmdForMathJax(editor, postfix, [["$", "$"], ["\\(","\\)"]]);
});
});
}, "mathjax-editing");
StackExchange.ready(function() {
var channelOptions = {
tags: "".split(" "),
id: "579"
};
initTagRenderer("".split(" "), "".split(" "), channelOptions);
StackExchange.using("externalEditor", function() {
// Have to fire editor after snippets, if snippets enabled
if (StackExchange.settings.snippets.snippetsEnabled) {
StackExchange.using("snippets", function() {
createEditor();
});
}
else {
createEditor();
}
});
function createEditor() {
StackExchange.prepareEditor({
heartbeatType: 'answer',
autoActivateHeartbeat: false,
convertImagesToLinks: false,
noModals: true,
showLowRepImageUploadWarning: true,
reputationToPostImages: null,
bindNavPrevention: true,
postfix: "",
imageUploader: {
brandingHtml: "Powered by u003ca class="icon-imgur-white" href="https://imgur.com/"u003eu003c/au003e",
contentPolicyHtml: "User contributions licensed under u003ca href="https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/3.0/"u003ecc by-sa 3.0 with attribution requiredu003c/au003e u003ca href="https://stackoverflow.com/legal/content-policy"u003e(content policy)u003c/au003e",
allowUrls: true
},
noCode: true, onDemand: true,
discardSelector: ".discard-answer"
,immediatelyShowMarkdownHelp:true
});
}
});
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function () {
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
});
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
StackExchange.ready(
function () {
StackExchange.openid.initPostLogin('.new-post-login', 'https%3a%2f%2fworldbuilding.stackexchange.com%2fquestions%2f135049%2fhow-long-can-an-adult-survive-on-pure-carbs%23new-answer', 'question_page');
}
);
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
3 Answers
3
active
oldest
votes
3 Answers
3
active
oldest
votes
active
oldest
votes
active
oldest
votes
A few months at best
It's the lack of vitamins that gets you.
Vitamin C deficiency is known colloquially as scurvy and was one of the biggest killers of sailors in the age of exploration.
Simply, you need your fruit and veg or you're going to die.
You can get around this if you have supplies of concentrated fruit juice or vitamin supplement pills, but you've got to have those vitamins.
2
Yep, scurvy was my first thought too.
– Tim B♦
1 hour ago
scurvy can be cured by extracting vitamin C from some evergreen trees, which are supposedly still healthy, by boiling the bark source. It's an old trick that european explorers learned from native american tribes when they first got there. Fruits come in season but trees always have bark, supposing our survivors know this they should be ok scurvy-wise
– Alexandre Aubrey
16 mins ago
add a comment |
A few months at best
It's the lack of vitamins that gets you.
Vitamin C deficiency is known colloquially as scurvy and was one of the biggest killers of sailors in the age of exploration.
Simply, you need your fruit and veg or you're going to die.
You can get around this if you have supplies of concentrated fruit juice or vitamin supplement pills, but you've got to have those vitamins.
2
Yep, scurvy was my first thought too.
– Tim B♦
1 hour ago
scurvy can be cured by extracting vitamin C from some evergreen trees, which are supposedly still healthy, by boiling the bark source. It's an old trick that european explorers learned from native american tribes when they first got there. Fruits come in season but trees always have bark, supposing our survivors know this they should be ok scurvy-wise
– Alexandre Aubrey
16 mins ago
add a comment |
A few months at best
It's the lack of vitamins that gets you.
Vitamin C deficiency is known colloquially as scurvy and was one of the biggest killers of sailors in the age of exploration.
Simply, you need your fruit and veg or you're going to die.
You can get around this if you have supplies of concentrated fruit juice or vitamin supplement pills, but you've got to have those vitamins.
A few months at best
It's the lack of vitamins that gets you.
Vitamin C deficiency is known colloquially as scurvy and was one of the biggest killers of sailors in the age of exploration.
Simply, you need your fruit and veg or you're going to die.
You can get around this if you have supplies of concentrated fruit juice or vitamin supplement pills, but you've got to have those vitamins.
edited 1 hour ago
answered 2 hours ago
Separatrix
76.8k30180304
76.8k30180304
2
Yep, scurvy was my first thought too.
– Tim B♦
1 hour ago
scurvy can be cured by extracting vitamin C from some evergreen trees, which are supposedly still healthy, by boiling the bark source. It's an old trick that european explorers learned from native american tribes when they first got there. Fruits come in season but trees always have bark, supposing our survivors know this they should be ok scurvy-wise
– Alexandre Aubrey
16 mins ago
add a comment |
2
Yep, scurvy was my first thought too.
– Tim B♦
1 hour ago
scurvy can be cured by extracting vitamin C from some evergreen trees, which are supposedly still healthy, by boiling the bark source. It's an old trick that european explorers learned from native american tribes when they first got there. Fruits come in season but trees always have bark, supposing our survivors know this they should be ok scurvy-wise
– Alexandre Aubrey
16 mins ago
2
2
Yep, scurvy was my first thought too.
– Tim B♦
1 hour ago
Yep, scurvy was my first thought too.
– Tim B♦
1 hour ago
scurvy can be cured by extracting vitamin C from some evergreen trees, which are supposedly still healthy, by boiling the bark source. It's an old trick that european explorers learned from native american tribes when they first got there. Fruits come in season but trees always have bark, supposing our survivors know this they should be ok scurvy-wise
– Alexandre Aubrey
16 mins ago
scurvy can be cured by extracting vitamin C from some evergreen trees, which are supposedly still healthy, by boiling the bark source. It's an old trick that european explorers learned from native american tribes when they first got there. Fruits come in season but trees always have bark, supposing our survivors know this they should be ok scurvy-wise
– Alexandre Aubrey
16 mins ago
add a comment |
Even if you have vitamin supplements stored, lack of fats will kill you before lack of protein. There's a phenomenon called "rabbit starvation" -- someone surviving in the wild whose only meat is wild rabbits will die in a few months because there isn't enough fat in the meat -- some vitamins are fat soluble and can't be absorbed, even with adequate vegetation in the diet, without enough fat intake.
Protein catabolism is a genuine issue: it's why people in WWII concentration camp photos look like living skeletons; their bodies have metabolized their own muscle to keep their brains and organs running. But if you have zero fat in a calorie-sufficient diet, you'll still waste and die even if there's enough protein to avoid digesting your own muscles.
Any idea how long that might take in an otherwise healthy (at first) adult?
– conman
1 hour ago
Given it was mentioned (by Les Stroud) as relevant to wilderness survival of someone who becomes lost in the deep woods, I'd guess the time period is two or three months -- certainly more than a week or two, likely less than half a year (anyone ought to be able to walk out in that kind of time, if they aren't injured or too weak from starvation).
– Zeiss Ikon
1 hour ago
1
Your body can make fats from carbohydrates it cant make protein from carbs. "rabbit starvation" aka protein poisoning. requires a lack of carbs as well. lack of protein may kill you first, PEM has a plethora of symptoms.
– John
23 mins ago
add a comment |
Even if you have vitamin supplements stored, lack of fats will kill you before lack of protein. There's a phenomenon called "rabbit starvation" -- someone surviving in the wild whose only meat is wild rabbits will die in a few months because there isn't enough fat in the meat -- some vitamins are fat soluble and can't be absorbed, even with adequate vegetation in the diet, without enough fat intake.
Protein catabolism is a genuine issue: it's why people in WWII concentration camp photos look like living skeletons; their bodies have metabolized their own muscle to keep their brains and organs running. But if you have zero fat in a calorie-sufficient diet, you'll still waste and die even if there's enough protein to avoid digesting your own muscles.
Any idea how long that might take in an otherwise healthy (at first) adult?
– conman
1 hour ago
Given it was mentioned (by Les Stroud) as relevant to wilderness survival of someone who becomes lost in the deep woods, I'd guess the time period is two or three months -- certainly more than a week or two, likely less than half a year (anyone ought to be able to walk out in that kind of time, if they aren't injured or too weak from starvation).
– Zeiss Ikon
1 hour ago
1
Your body can make fats from carbohydrates it cant make protein from carbs. "rabbit starvation" aka protein poisoning. requires a lack of carbs as well. lack of protein may kill you first, PEM has a plethora of symptoms.
– John
23 mins ago
add a comment |
Even if you have vitamin supplements stored, lack of fats will kill you before lack of protein. There's a phenomenon called "rabbit starvation" -- someone surviving in the wild whose only meat is wild rabbits will die in a few months because there isn't enough fat in the meat -- some vitamins are fat soluble and can't be absorbed, even with adequate vegetation in the diet, without enough fat intake.
Protein catabolism is a genuine issue: it's why people in WWII concentration camp photos look like living skeletons; their bodies have metabolized their own muscle to keep their brains and organs running. But if you have zero fat in a calorie-sufficient diet, you'll still waste and die even if there's enough protein to avoid digesting your own muscles.
Even if you have vitamin supplements stored, lack of fats will kill you before lack of protein. There's a phenomenon called "rabbit starvation" -- someone surviving in the wild whose only meat is wild rabbits will die in a few months because there isn't enough fat in the meat -- some vitamins are fat soluble and can't be absorbed, even with adequate vegetation in the diet, without enough fat intake.
Protein catabolism is a genuine issue: it's why people in WWII concentration camp photos look like living skeletons; their bodies have metabolized their own muscle to keep their brains and organs running. But if you have zero fat in a calorie-sufficient diet, you'll still waste and die even if there's enough protein to avoid digesting your own muscles.
answered 1 hour ago
Zeiss Ikon
1,023110
1,023110
Any idea how long that might take in an otherwise healthy (at first) adult?
– conman
1 hour ago
Given it was mentioned (by Les Stroud) as relevant to wilderness survival of someone who becomes lost in the deep woods, I'd guess the time period is two or three months -- certainly more than a week or two, likely less than half a year (anyone ought to be able to walk out in that kind of time, if they aren't injured or too weak from starvation).
– Zeiss Ikon
1 hour ago
1
Your body can make fats from carbohydrates it cant make protein from carbs. "rabbit starvation" aka protein poisoning. requires a lack of carbs as well. lack of protein may kill you first, PEM has a plethora of symptoms.
– John
23 mins ago
add a comment |
Any idea how long that might take in an otherwise healthy (at first) adult?
– conman
1 hour ago
Given it was mentioned (by Les Stroud) as relevant to wilderness survival of someone who becomes lost in the deep woods, I'd guess the time period is two or three months -- certainly more than a week or two, likely less than half a year (anyone ought to be able to walk out in that kind of time, if they aren't injured or too weak from starvation).
– Zeiss Ikon
1 hour ago
1
Your body can make fats from carbohydrates it cant make protein from carbs. "rabbit starvation" aka protein poisoning. requires a lack of carbs as well. lack of protein may kill you first, PEM has a plethora of symptoms.
– John
23 mins ago
Any idea how long that might take in an otherwise healthy (at first) adult?
– conman
1 hour ago
Any idea how long that might take in an otherwise healthy (at first) adult?
– conman
1 hour ago
Given it was mentioned (by Les Stroud) as relevant to wilderness survival of someone who becomes lost in the deep woods, I'd guess the time period is two or three months -- certainly more than a week or two, likely less than half a year (anyone ought to be able to walk out in that kind of time, if they aren't injured or too weak from starvation).
– Zeiss Ikon
1 hour ago
Given it was mentioned (by Les Stroud) as relevant to wilderness survival of someone who becomes lost in the deep woods, I'd guess the time period is two or three months -- certainly more than a week or two, likely less than half a year (anyone ought to be able to walk out in that kind of time, if they aren't injured or too weak from starvation).
– Zeiss Ikon
1 hour ago
1
1
Your body can make fats from carbohydrates it cant make protein from carbs. "rabbit starvation" aka protein poisoning. requires a lack of carbs as well. lack of protein may kill you first, PEM has a plethora of symptoms.
– John
23 mins ago
Your body can make fats from carbohydrates it cant make protein from carbs. "rabbit starvation" aka protein poisoning. requires a lack of carbs as well. lack of protein may kill you first, PEM has a plethora of symptoms.
– John
23 mins ago
add a comment |
Not a problem.
There are literally food sources all around us. The only way your survivors would have to survive on "junk food" is if they were somehow trapped in an industrial city or in the middle of a desert, and even then they would learn to find alternate sources of food as part of surviving. If it's a situation where they have adequate clean water, they'll be able to find edibles.
Once they manage to get into the country, they should very quickly find other survivors who actually know how to grow food and/or have a rough understanding of which wild foods are good to eat. Heck, they'll find good food literally growing on trees or out of the ground, if they come upon an orchard or a cabbage farm.
add a comment |
Not a problem.
There are literally food sources all around us. The only way your survivors would have to survive on "junk food" is if they were somehow trapped in an industrial city or in the middle of a desert, and even then they would learn to find alternate sources of food as part of surviving. If it's a situation where they have adequate clean water, they'll be able to find edibles.
Once they manage to get into the country, they should very quickly find other survivors who actually know how to grow food and/or have a rough understanding of which wild foods are good to eat. Heck, they'll find good food literally growing on trees or out of the ground, if they come upon an orchard or a cabbage farm.
add a comment |
Not a problem.
There are literally food sources all around us. The only way your survivors would have to survive on "junk food" is if they were somehow trapped in an industrial city or in the middle of a desert, and even then they would learn to find alternate sources of food as part of surviving. If it's a situation where they have adequate clean water, they'll be able to find edibles.
Once they manage to get into the country, they should very quickly find other survivors who actually know how to grow food and/or have a rough understanding of which wild foods are good to eat. Heck, they'll find good food literally growing on trees or out of the ground, if they come upon an orchard or a cabbage farm.
Not a problem.
There are literally food sources all around us. The only way your survivors would have to survive on "junk food" is if they were somehow trapped in an industrial city or in the middle of a desert, and even then they would learn to find alternate sources of food as part of surviving. If it's a situation where they have adequate clean water, they'll be able to find edibles.
Once they manage to get into the country, they should very quickly find other survivors who actually know how to grow food and/or have a rough understanding of which wild foods are good to eat. Heck, they'll find good food literally growing on trees or out of the ground, if they come upon an orchard or a cabbage farm.
answered 3 mins ago
Adam Miller
1,566716
1,566716
add a comment |
add a comment |
Thanks for contributing an answer to Worldbuilding Stack Exchange!
- Please be sure to answer the question. Provide details and share your research!
But avoid …
- Asking for help, clarification, or responding to other answers.
- Making statements based on opinion; back them up with references or personal experience.
Use MathJax to format equations. MathJax reference.
To learn more, see our tips on writing great answers.
Some of your past answers have not been well-received, and you're in danger of being blocked from answering.
Please pay close attention to the following guidance:
- Please be sure to answer the question. Provide details and share your research!
But avoid …
- Asking for help, clarification, or responding to other answers.
- Making statements based on opinion; back them up with references or personal experience.
To learn more, see our tips on writing great answers.
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function () {
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
});
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
StackExchange.ready(
function () {
StackExchange.openid.initPostLogin('.new-post-login', 'https%3a%2f%2fworldbuilding.stackexchange.com%2fquestions%2f135049%2fhow-long-can-an-adult-survive-on-pure-carbs%23new-answer', 'question_page');
}
);
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function () {
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
});
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function () {
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
});
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function () {
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
});
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Dry pasta is roughly 10% protein (albeit not a complete protein.) Kept dry, it can last a long time. This is higher than white or even brown rice. On the other hand, unpopped popcorn could be used as planting seed, as could most dry beans.
– Catalyst
2 hours ago
Please clarify: Is the question how long one can survive on a fairly-pure carb diet (e.g. just white rice?) OR, is the question what are the most valuable additions to that diet, to make it viable in the long term? Or something else entirely??
– Catalyst
1 hour ago
2
Dry beans also keep a long time and are a complete protein, with pretty good vitamin content. Not sure how long you'd stay sane living on beans and nothing else, but you could live a long time...
– Zeiss Ikon
1 hour ago
@Catalyst the former: how long can one survive on a fairly pure-carb diet? Your other question is basically "what can a post-apocalyptic scavenger do to improve nutrition?" which is related and of interest to me, but I think it would be too broad to throw that in as well. However, I think it would be fair to tell me if my main assumption (i.e. pure carbs are the primary food source) is wrong.
– conman
49 mins ago